Mutual Funds Or Index Funds: Where Should You Invest In 2026?
Index funds and mutual funds are two of the most common methods for investors to gain exposure to diversified portfolios without purchasing individual stocks.
Mutual funds are managed actively. Fund managers personally select investments based on research, market trends, and targets. Their target is to beat benchmarks. This active management provides flexibility but results in higher management fees due to ongoing analysis and trading, and potential under-performance.
Index funds, on the other hand, employ a passive approach. They replicate a particular benchmark index, such as the Nifty 50, by maintaining its component stocks in identical percentages. They neither try to beat the market nor do they try to be otherwise. The simplicity of the "buy and hold" approach rather leads to much lower expense ratios.
The total assets under management (AUM) of mutual funds increased from approximately INR 27 trillion towards the end of July 2020 to approximately INR 75.36 trillion as of July 2025, translating to a mammoth increase of almost more than three times in a span of five years1.
Passive funds constituted nearly 17% of this giant industry by June 2025. Passive investing has now started getting traction with lower costs, higher transparency, and consistent performance2.
Keep reading to learn how index fund vs mutual fund can impact your portfolio.
Index Fund Vs Mutual Fund: How They Differ in Structure and Management?
The structure and management are completely different for index funds and mutual funds.
Active Management (Mutual Funds)
Professional fund managers or a team make investment decisions, use their own analysis and judgment based on their research to select stocks to invest in. They dissect market trends, company accounts, economic conditions, and even ESG considerations to know what to buy, hold, or sell. They pivot investments to outperform a benchmark, such as the Nifty 50 or S&P 500.
This hands-on decision-making relies on fundamentals and quantitative analysis. Fund managers directly manage portfolios to react to market movements or match investor objectives. This ability allows for customisation, such as tilting in the direction of dividends, cutting tech exposure, or entering sustainable investing based on strategy or mandate.
Active funds typically charge higher fees to cover research and trading costs. Frequent trading also makes it less tax-efficient.
Passive Tracking (Index Funds)
Index funds take a different approach: they track a benchmark index instead of attempting to outperform it. Managers construct portfolios that replicate the holdings of the index either by maintaining every component ("full replication") or a sample representation ("sampling") and rebalancing from time to time to keep pace with changes.
Passive management is a "buy and hold" approach. The portfolio only changes when the index itself changes. Minimal turnover reduces costs, fees and improves tax efficiency. One of the most important functions for passive fund managers is tracking error tightly, measuring how closely the fund tracks the index, and dealing with dividends correctly.
Returns vs Risk: What Should Indian Investors Choose?
Understanding risks and returns for both kinds of investment options is crucial to deciding which one has better performance.
Here is how you can determine index funds vs actively managed mutual funds with respect to these factors:
Historical Return Trends in India (2020–2025)
Here are the index funds vs mutual funds returns India has:
Year | Mutual Funds(p.a) | Index Funds(p.a) |
2020 | 25-35% | 14-15% |
2021 | 18-22% | 24% |
2022 | 8-12% | 4-5% |
2023 | 15-18% | 20% |
2024 | 15-18% | 8-9% |
2025 | 9-10% | 6% |
Risk Levels And Volatility
Index fund investments are directly exposed to the volatility of the underlying index. For example, if the Nifty 50 index has historically shown annualized volatility of 16.6%, this volatility can cause fluctuations in your investment values.
Active mutual funds have comparatively higher risks. These funds can experience significant volatility, but also offer a potential for higher returns. An example of such is the FY2025, where small-cap funds faced sharp corrections, although they still outperformed their benchmarks.
Also Read: Market Volatility And Investment: Navigating Ups And Downs For Financial Success
Why Expense Ratio Could Eat Into Your Gains
Sometimes, in the case of mutual or index funds, several people focus only on returns without paying much attention to the expense ratio. The expense ratio is the annual fee that a fund charges to manage your money.
Although this fee percentage is typically seen as a small amount, it still has the power to reduce your overall returns, especially during long-term investments. Therefore, understanding the expense ratio can help you manage your funds and make better investment decisions.
Why Index Funds Are Cheaper
Index funds are a part of passive investing in India.. This means that these funds do not require a team of experts or a fund manager to choose stocks. Instead, the fund invests in each stock in the same proportion as represented in the index. With no payment for experts and lower research costs, the overall operational costs are much lower as well.
In contrast, mutual funds are managed by professionals through research, analyzing market trends, making trading decisions, etc. And such management comes with higher costs. It requires higher fees for professional management, costs associated with buying and selling securities, and more.
Do Lower Fees Always Mean Better Returns?
Lower fees can significantly impact your long-term investments. You can do so by preserving your capital and magnifying your returns. Two funds with the same gross rate, but different fees, can yield different returns over 10 to 15 years, while favoring the low-fee fund.
However, lower fees do not necessarily mean better returns. Active funds can outperform index funds in specific market conditions. Fund managers often justify their high fees with the promise of high returns as well. However, with consistency, even index funds can have higher returns.
Also Read: Hybrid Mutual Funds Taxation: Rules, Rates And How It Impacts You In 2025
Which One Is Better For Your Portfolio In 2026?
As of 2025, many investors keep choosing index funds as a safe and secure option. It has low costs, it is transparent, and has consistent performance with the market benchmarks, all of which make it perfect for beginners, passive investors, and goal-based planners.
Although investors who are much more experienced and are not afraid of market risks often go for mutual funds. This is especially because these funds have higher returns and are actively managed funds in different categories, all of which can add a lot of value to your portfolio.
Therefore, the better investment for your portfolio completely depends on your experience as an investor. Moreover, you can also opt for both of these options to get maximum benefits.
Conclusion
With a wide range of investment options available in 2026, selecting the right one becomes essential to avoid costly financial mistakes. The choice between mutual funds and index funds largely depends on your investment goals, risk appetite, time horizon, and how actively you want to manage your portfolio. Understanding the key differences between these options will help you choose what works best, whether it’s high-growth equity mutual funds or low-cost, passive index funds.
For investors looking to go beyond traditional choices, Grip Invest offers curated opportunities in fixed-income products like corporate bonds and lease-based investments, designed for stable returns and portfolio diversification.
FAQs On Mutual Funds Vs Index Funds
1. Are index funds safer than mutual funds?
Index funds are comparatively considered safer than mutual funds for several reasons. These funds track broad market indexes and are managed passively, which minimizes human errors. However, there is still market risk as they do not provide protection against market downturns.
2. Which gives better returns in India: mutual funds or index funds?
For better returns in India, it is typically better to choose active mutual funds over index funds. Mutual funds offer higher returns, especially in mid and small-cap segments. However, in long-term investments, index funds also match up or outperform mutual funds.
3. Is it better to start a SIP in an index fund or a mutual fund?
For SIP in index funds vs mutual funds, remember that a low-cost, long-term investment, it is ideal to start a SIP in an index fund. Mutual fund SIPs may offer higher returns, but require more time and involvement in fund selection and performance tracking.
4. Can index funds beat actively managed mutual funds in India?
Yes, it is possible for index funds to beat mutual funds in India, especially the ones with large-cap segments, lower fees, and consistent performance. However, sometimes mutual funds in certain categories can still outperform, depending on market cycles and the fund manager.
References:
1. Association of Mutual Funds India, accessed from: https://www.moneycontrol.com/mutual-funds/performance-tracker/returns/index-fundsetfs.html
2. Economic Times, accessed from: https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/markets/bonds/passive-funds-gain-traction-now-17-of-indias-rs-74-lakh-crore-mf-industry/articleshow/123112166.cms
Want to stay at the top of your finances?
Join the community of 4 lakh+ investors and learn more about Grip Invest, the latest financial knick-knacks and shenanigans that take place in the world of investing.
Happy Investing!
Disclaimer - Investments in debt securities/municipal debt securities/securitised debt instruments are subject to risks including delay and/ or default in payment. Read all the offer related documents carefully. The investor is requested to take into consideration all the risk factors before the commencement of trading.
This communication is prepared by Grip Broking Private Limited (bearing SEBI Registration No. INZ000312836 and NSE ID 90319) and/or its affiliate/ group company(ies) (together referred to as “Grip”) and the contents of this disclaimer are applicable to this document and any and all written or oral communication(s) made by Grip or its directors, employees, associates, representatives and agents. This communication does not constitute advice relating to investing or otherwise dealing in securities and is not an offer or solicitation for the purchase or sale of any securities. Grip does not guarantee or assure any return on investments and accepts no liability for consequences of any actions taken based on the information provided. For more details, please visit www.gripinvest.in
Registered Address - 106, II F, New Asiatic Building, H Block, Connaught Place, New Delhi 110001
